Saturday, July 9, 2011

The State of the Game: Dungeons & Dragons

As the grand old game once again find itself in flux, it seems these trips to the ancient manuscript files are both poignant and interesting, well at least they are to me...

Comments on the state of the game by Gary Gygax (Dragon #14, 1978)


Not a few D&D enthusiasts are puzzled about what is going on with the game. They are wondering what the ‘new “Basic Set” of D&D is, will the Original game be around much longer, and what ADVANCED D&D is and when it will be available. As briefly as possible, I will attempt to answer all such questions, for we have no desire to confuse DMs and players as to what is taking place.

Before the third supplement (ELDRITCH WIZARDRY) was in print, it had been decided that some major steps would have to be taken to unify and clarify the D&D game system. This project began then, but such a long and complex. task cannot be accomplished quickly if it is to be done right, and if nothing else we were determined to do it right! Organizational work was in progress when correspondence with J. Eric Holmes, professor, author and incidentally a respected neurologist, disclosed that the Good Doctor was interested in undertaking the first stage of the project — the rewriting and editing necessary to extract a beginner’s set of D&D from the basic set and its supplements. The result of his labors is the “Basic Set” of D&D.

“Basic” D&D does not differ greatly from the Original except that it is far better structured — thus far more understandable for an individual previously not acquainted with the concept of fantasy role playing.
The rules clarify things and are changed in a few minor areas which do not materially affect existing campaigns. There are a few new first and second level spells. It is important to note, however, that the
“Basic Set” is NOT aimed at the existing group of enthusiasts, it is designed solely for new players. It has rules which take players only through the first three experience levels! If they enjoy the game they must then obtain either AD&D or D&D. As advertisements have boldly proclaimed, the set has everything needed to BEGIN PLAYING D&D, Whether or not the work is purchased for purposes of having a complete collection of D&D material, IT IS NOT NECESSARY FOR PLAYERS ALREADY ACQUAINTED WITH THE MECHANICS OF DUNGEONS & DRAGONS. Well then, what about references in the new work which direct the reader to ADVANCED DUNGEONS & DRAGONS? you might well ask.

The “Basic Set” was done with care, and it can lead to either the Original game or to the new, as yet unfinished, ADVANCED D&D. Because of the numerous supplements and articles necessary to make D&D a more easily understandable and multifaceted game, we decided that a whole new game was in order. There were too many gray areas in the Original, too many different books, too many varying approaches offered. However, the first work will never be done away with, for it offers a system which still attracts many persons. Whether from a nostalgia standpoint, from a desire to collect anything pertaining to D&D, or because of the content which will be excluded from the concept of the new game, we at TSR are certain that Original D&D will always be in demand. The-only part of the system which will be revised to fit into ADVANCED DUNGEONS & DRAGONS is Supplement IV, GODS, DEMI-GODS, & HEROES. Here is what the new game will consist of:

ADVANCED DUNGEONS & DRAGONS, MONSTER MANUAL was anticipated to be ready prior to Christmas. (As usual, there were delays, mainly from the printer and the binder.) I am drafting the final manuscript for the player’s book, and a rough outline of the referee’s volume is on hand, so work on that can commence as soon as the former is completed. Furthermore, Messrs. Kuntz and Ward are hard at work revising the G, D-G, H supplement so that it will be ready to go into print late in 1978 or in early ‘79. The player’s and referee’s books should be available in the summer of ‘78. Thus, A D&D will consist of four books — three main parts and a supplement. The MONSTER MANUAL and GODS, DEMIGODS, & HEROES will fit into the Original game system with a bit of care on the part of the Dungeon Master, if such is desired. But all-in-all, ADVANCED DUNGEONS & DRAGONS is a new game. To state this in terms of existing boardgames, for example, AD&D and D&D will bear the same relationship as STALINGRAD does to RUSSIAN CAMPAIGN. The former is a truly classic game, but the latter is even better. Nonetheless, devotees will wish to have both! Furthermore, to carry the analogy a bit further, parts of RUSSIAN CAMPAIGN can be incorporated into STALINGRAD to give the latter new horizons in respect to the strategies and tactics of play. While each game will retain a following which adhere only to one or the other, most players will certainly wish to have both regardless of which they find themselves playing more frequently.

In summation, the “Basic Set” of D&D is aimed at new players, those persons as yet uninitiated to the wonders of fantasy role playing. While it channels these new adventurers towards the ADVANCED game, with its better ordered and more clear rules, it suits such players for play of the Original game just as well. Nearly all of the Original booklets will remain unchanged and in print, only G, D-G, & H will be revised to fit into ADVANCED D&D. The whole of AD&D will be a better, cleaner system aimed at improving the understanding of the role playing game system. The first three books, the main part, will be ready in mid-1978 if all goes as expected. I am certain that you will find them worth the wait!

Rogue Space d20

Thursday, July 7, 2011

Holmes compares his Basic D&D boxed set to the Moldvay Basic D&D boxed set

From Dragon Magazine #52

by J. Eric Holmes
Editor, first edition
D&D® Basic Set rules

The first thing to realize about the rules for the DUNGEONS & DRAGONS® Basic Set is for whom they are written. Most of you reading this article already know how to play a D&D® or AD&D™ game. Most of you learned how to play by watching a game or having a friend guide you through your first game. If you have seen a game played, the rules are pretty easy to understand. But the D&D Basic Rulebook is written for people who have never seen a game. It is intended to teach the game to someone who’s coming to it for the first time. All other considerations should be secondary to teaching how to play the game with a minimum of confusion. I like to think that the first Basic Set did just that.

The new edition of the Basic Set, edited by Tom Moldvay, certainly does so as well. The second edition, as sold in the boxed set with dice and D&D Module B2, The Keep on the Borderlands by Gary Gygax, is the best possible introduction to the D&D game. Those of us who are already playing D&D games will be able to find lots of things to “complain” about (Why only seven character classes? Heal light wounds cures paralysis? A charmed Magic-User is too confused to do magic? Boy, that last rule would make a dramatic change in the conduct of my game, where the player characters would be apt to yell, “Don’t kill the evil magician! Let me try to charm him first, then use him to wipe out the rest of the monsters on this level.“).

But actually these are minor quibbles to someone who is just learning to play. When Tactical Studies Rules published the first DUNGEONS & DRAGONS rule sets, the three little books in brown covers, they were intended to guide people who were already playing the game. As a guide to learning the game, they were incomprehensible. There was no description of the use of the combat table. Magic spells were listed, but there was no mention of what we all now know is a vital aspect of the rules: that as the magic user says his spell, the words and gestures for it fade from his memory and he cannot say it again.

When I edited the rules prior to the first edition of the D&D Basic Set, it was to help the thousands (now millions) of people who wanted to play the game and didn’t know how to get started. Gary Gygax acknowledged that some sort of beginner’s book was badly needed, and he encouraged me to go ahead with it. What I discovered is that the invention has four vital parts: The first is character generation (the traditional 3d6 determination of characteristics). This character section must also include rules for different races and for special talents. There must be rules for character advancement of some sort. The second part concerns magic (or, in a science-fiction game, high technology, which is the same thing). Rules must be given for how to perform magic, who has magical abilities, etc. There must be a list of allowable spells and their prerequisites. There must be rules for possible spell failure, for saving throws, for magic resistance and so forth.

Third, a section on “the encounter.” This is mostly rules for combat and the all-important combat table, but there also need to be rules for movement, for hiding and detection (listening at doors), for negotiation and monster reactions, for running away, and so forth.

Finally, there needs to be a section of the rulebook intended for the DM. This includes descriptions of monsters and nonplayer characters, and treasures and magical items. It also includes guidelines for setting up and conducting adventures, usually with several examples.

I struggled very hard to make all these things clear to the readers of the first Basic Rules and yet retain the flavor and excitement of the original rules. I even used the words of the DUNGEONS & DRAGONS Collectors Edition (the original books) whenever possible. I had disagreements with Gary over some items (I wanted to use a spell point system, for instance), but we kept the rules as close as possible to the original intent.

D&D is, after ail, a truly unique invention, probably as remarkable as the die, or the deck of cards, or the chessboard. The inventor’s vision needs to be respected. The first Basic Set rulebook contained some irritating typographical errors. Someone at TSR rewrote the wandering monster table and put in a number of creatures that were not in my list of monster descriptions. But most of the errors were corrected for the second printing.

The second edition Basic Set makes a number of minor changes and adds 18 pages’ worth of new material to the booklet. Most of the changes and additions are, I think, improvements. I would like to examine a few of them more closely.

Character classes: Player characters are restricted to being a Fighter, Cleric, Thief, Magic-User, Elf, Halfling or Dwarf. This probably covers the roles most beginning players want to try, but I am personally sorry to see the range of possibilities so restricted. The original rules (the three little brown books) specifically stated that a player could be a dragon if he wanted to be, and if he started at first level. For several years there was a dragon player character in my own game. At first level he could puff a little fire and do one die of damage. He could, of course, fly, even at first level. He was one of the most unpopular characters in the game, but this was because of the way he was played, not because he was a dragon. I enjoyed having dragons, centaurs, samurai and witch doctors in the game. My own most successful player character was a Dreenoi, an insectoid creature borrowed from McEwan’s Starguard. He reached fourth level (as high as any of my personal characters ever got), made an unfortunate decision, and was turned into a pool of green slime.

Character alignment: This is the most difficult of the D&D concepts to get across. The new rules spend more space on alignments and do a much better job of explaining them, using practical examples. Alignment is Law, Chaos and Neutral. Good and Evil are not discussed as separate alignments at all, which I think makes better sense. The first Basic Set had one of those diagrams which said that blink dogs were lawful good and brass dragons were chaotic good. I never felt that this was particularly helpful. I am sure Gary Gygax has an idea in his mind of what chaotic good (or other “obscure” alignments, etc.) may be, but it certainly isn’t clear to me. Without meaning to be irreverent, I am also sure that Buddha knew what he meant by nirvana, but that doesn’t clarify it in my mind either. I think the new rules simplify the issue appropriately.

Armor Class: The new rulebook continues to avoid the unnecessary proliferation of armor types found in the AD&D game, which also incorporates splint mail, scale mail, and ring mail. This is good, but herein also lies a missed opportunity. I think the numbering system should have been adjusted to make plate armor and shield, the best non-magical protection possible, AC 1. Then all magic armor could be represented by zero or negative numbers to indicate armor class. A minor point, at best.

While I am on the armor and equipment page, “mace” should have been included in the glossary (and the very existence of a glossary is a tremendous improvement). Many modern-day players think “mace” is an aerosol can of tear gas!

Magic and spells: The new rules specify that if an adventure lasts longer than a day, the Magic-User can get his or her spells back through a period of rest and concentration. I’m glad to see this securely placed in the rules. All of us who act as Dungeon Masters have had to allow this on longer adventures. Actually, the “spell book” is often a needless complication and can be dispensed with. Of course, a particular DM can make spell books a vital part of the game— suppose evil Magic-Users hired a high-level Thief to steal the player characters’ books?

Phantasmal force has been added to the available spell list. The list is still much shorter than that in the original D&D rules or in the AD&D books. Phantasmal force has been appropriately weakened in the new rules, however; even if the victim fails a saving throw, he or she is not permanently harmed by the phantasm. If determined to be killed, the character actually only passes out, and recovers in 1d4 turns. Presumably, hit points lost in this manner are also restored after 1-4 turns. This makes the phantasmal force a much fairer attack. With the old spell, the M-U could summon a dragon or demon and, if the poor victim failed his saving throw trying to disbelieve it, he was as good as dead. A phantom, it seems to me, should indeed be terrifying, but basically harmless.

Organizing a Party, The Caller: I think this rule should have been thrown out. I put it into the first Basic Set because it was in the original invention. I have never seen a successful game where one of the players was elected caller and actually did all the talking to the DM. Usually everybody talks at once. The resulting confusion is much more lifelike; one can hear the characters dithering at the cross corridor as the monsters approach. “Run this way!” “Charge them!” “Get out of the way, I’m throwing a spell!” “Here goes the magic crossbow bolt!” “Not from the rear of the party!” “I’m climbing the wall!”

As the players learn to work together as a team, a leader will often evolve. I think it is more fun to always allow a character to call out his or her own action and see the consternation on the other players’ faces. Also, this encourages the shy player (yes, there are shy players!) to get into the swing of things. “What’s
your halfling going to do?”

Infravision: Saying that infravision is the ability to “see” heat patterns is putting a magical ability into terms of mundane universe physics. I think it would have been better to leave it as pure magic. I know this “heat seeing” explanation is the one favored by Gygax, but it embraces too many inconsistencies.
Living creatures give off heat. Okay, but how about the undead? Do they appear as spots of cold? If so, a dwarf or elf can always identify a vampire by looking at him in the dark. What about inanimate objects? If a monster (all monsters have infravision) charges into a room, can he see the furniture before he runs into it? How about a rope stretched across the corridor? It would have been better just to say, “It’s magic.”

The Encounter: Moldvay correctly stresses the importance of using “turn” when a one-minute turn is meant, and “round” for a ten-second round, and not mixing them up. How much confusion would have been avoided if the rules had always followed this simple edict!

The new rules introduce surprise and initiative die rolls into the combat situation. I had merely had the creature with the highest dexterity strike first. The initiative roll makes combat a good deal more chancy, and I’m not sure I like it. I will not object, to it on the basis of its being less “realistic,” however!

The game’s entire combat system has been criticized for being unrealistic, and many game designers have tried to improve upon it, but with little success. It is possible to make a combat system that is more like a real hand-to-hand battle, but then it takes too long. Combat and magic are the high points of an adventure, but you don’t want the rules to be so complicated that a beginning player can’t master them. And, even when your character’s life is at stake, doing innumerable die rolls for every move can get boring. The present system is fast and workable.

Critics who complain about its lack of realism have forgotten that it is not intended to be a simulation of real combat. It is a simulation of combat as it occurs in most fantasy novels, and at this it succeeds admirably. The combat sequence has been slightly and appropriately changed. The new rules provide for fighting withdrawal as well as retreat, and there is always the possibility of a hit (20) and always the possibility of a miss (1). These are improvements over the original system.

Monsters are given a morale rating. If they fail a morale check during combat, they try to flee or surrender. Player characters, of course, are incredibly brave and may fight to the death if they wish. This “run away, run away!” rule for monsters is a good one, and allows for far more interesting fights and more satisfying victories for the players. The DM, if he wants to be sneaky, can have those fleeing orcs make a bid for revenge.

They would be likely to set up a trap or an ambush to catch the unwary characters on their way back out of the dungeon. They might go down a level and try to negotiate an alliance with a more fearsome monster from the depths to come up and help them get even! I think the present combat system lacks only one device common to sword and- sorcery tales, but it is one so commonly used that I miss it in the game. There is very little chance for the hero to be knocked out and taken prisoner. Yet, that is so frequently what happens in a fictional battle. True, there is a provision in the rules for subduing dragons by “attacking with the flat of the sword,” etc., which could be extended to other creatures. It requires declaring at the start of melee that one is trying for subdual, and it does not provide for “knocked out” as a result of ordinary combat. In ordinary combat you are either alive or dead! Perhaps inserting a “knockout” rule would needlessly complicate the system, but when I think of all the times John Carter or Conan was overwhelmed by enemies and came to in some sort of dungeon trap, I miss the opportunity to re-enact some of their situations.

Monsters: There is a much more extensive monster list in this second edition, including many not in the AD&D Monster Manual. This gives the beginning DM plenty to work with. I’m glad to see Moldvay included the dragons just as I did in the first edition. It seems almost silly to describe dragons in a book intended only for player characters up to the third level. On the other hand, think how disappointed you would be if you were an inexperienced player who bought a DUNGEONS & DRAGONS game and found nothing about dragons inside!

The rulebook continues with a section on treasure and an example of how to plan a scenario and draw your first map. The section “Dungeon Mastering as a fine art” has been expanded. The beginning DM is given advice on dealing with “That’s not in the rules!” “Your character doesn’t know that!” and other crises that arise in a beginners’ game. Excellent: The more help we can give the poor DM, the better.

There is a page-long list of “inspirational source material” which is more complete than the one given in the AD&D Dungeon Masters Guide. I didn’t have such a list in the first edition; this is someone else’s inspired idea. I wish I’d thought of it. Do you know there may be people out there playing a D&D game who have never read The Lord of the Rings?

Finally, there is a glossary (which complements the one in The Keep on the Borderlands) and, hallelujah, an index! Any book this complicated needs an index. The original Basic Set had a final page of tables which could be torn out and used for reference. I wish it had been included again.

A few comments on the other components in the new Basic Set: First, there’s the module, The Keep on the Borderlands. This is, in my opinion, the best thing Gygax has written for us yet. It contains all kinds of hints for the DM and the players. There’s enough stuff on the map to keep a low-level party busy adventuring for weeks. Truly a bargain.

Then there’s the dice. When the first of Basic Set was marketed, it included a set very cheap dice. I was, understandably, proud of the project, and every time I met a D&D player for the first time, I would introduce myself as the “editor of the Basic Set.”
“The what?”
“You know, the box that has the big dragon on the cover.”
 “Oh, yeah,” my new acquaintance would say, “the one with the really ugly dice.”
 “But I didn’t have anything to do with picking the dice!” I would cry.

Well, the second edition has a different set of dice. The 20-sided die is numbered from 1 to 20. (Now there’s an innovation.) Unfortunately, the dice are small, hard to read even when marked with crayon, and, let’s face it, really ugly. I’m sorry, Tom, but it looks like you too are going to have to go through the next few years feeling responsible for ugly dice!

I think the new Basic Set rules are an improvement over the first edition. Not a big quantum jump ahead, but better in a number of minor ways. I’m proud of the original Basic Set, and I like to think I did a good job of describing a great invention; the DUNGEONS & DRAGONS game, so that everyone could enjoy it. The nicest compliment I ever got for it was from a game-store manager who said, “That’s made a lot of people happy.” May the new edition do the same.

Monday, July 4, 2011

A pocket full of BUCKSHOT

Check it out and download it for free on my Buckshot RPG site. Happy 4th of July!

Sunday, July 3, 2011

Traveller RPG + your iPhone = Traveller AR

This is quite interesting.  I dig my iPhone for gaming (roguelikes) and watching baseball on the go, but I have had zero interest in MMO's.  Even the Conan one wasn't enough to tempt me.  But a Traveller based one?  On my iPhone?  I am interested only from the following standpoint: Who is this aimed at?

I don't think the Traveller brand has much power, especially outside the RPG community.  So this is for SciFi RPG gamers with phones?  Hmmm seems like a pretty small market.  Especially as an MMO...on your phone? yes that probably makes me older than dirt, but seriosuly, outside of killing time between flights (or on them) I don't use my phone for gaming much, and certainly not for hours at a time.  Anyway enough of the "get off my lawn" talk.  Let's talk about Traveller AR. 

It appears to be a true Traveller RPG experience: All the classes, all the alien races, and even HexMode exploration which looks like the classic subsector  maps. 


From the Traveller-AR Site:
Traveller AR comes with some fantastic features which will help make it the iPhone space game of choice, and one of the best iPhone MMO games in the iPhone store.
  • Vast empire to explore
  • Completely MMO – You will be playing with real people in real time.
  • iPhone RPG – Based on the fantastic Traveller RPG story-line, allowing you to explore the universe from anywhere
  • Augmented Reality – overlay the real world with the traveller universe.
  • Unique Nav Wheel helps you easily navigate the virtual world.
  • The traditional hex mode has been used to allow Traveller players to easily pick up the Traveller AR iPhone RPG.
  • A wide selection of ships and character classes to choose from.
They are running a major event at Comic Con this year so I will give it a try there, not sure I will stick with it, but its worth a shot and an honest review.

Saturday, July 2, 2011

Commentary: Dragon Magzine #52, Moldvay Basic D&D Boxed set

You can read the article uninterrupted in my previous post today. I have added my own commentary to the Moldvay self review of the 2nd edition D&D Basic Set. My comments are in italics.

by Tom Moldvay
Editor, second edition
D&D® Basic Set rules

Why was a new edition of the D&D® Basic Set rules needed?

First of all, it was necessary for the Basic rules to be in the same format as their sequel, the D&D Expert Set rules. Otherwise, it would be difficult to use the two sets together, as they were meant to be used. The D&D Expert rules build on the D&D Basic rules, they do not replace them.

This makes great sense from a strictly cohesive brand presentation and rules format.  Interesting that Zeb Cook’s expert rules seem to have preceded Moldvay’s basic? Even more interesting is if true, Cook’s Expert rules must have started the change in format and goal from Holmes’ basic rules. Holmes Basic seems like a cleaned up intro to the LBB game.  B/X feels more like a complete revision.

Second, good as it was, the earlier edition still had minor flaws. The large number of questions received by TSR Hobbies showed that many areas of the D&D rules were still difficult for beginners to grasp. It was necessary to reorganize and re-edit the rules, keeping in mind that most new D&D players are not hard-core gamers and have never played a role-playing game before.

While the LBB’s were more  the realm of experienced gamers and the Holmes version tried to provide a bridge between LBB’s and an entry level product, it’s clear that Holmes’s Basic set was still too difficult for the masses to consume. I don’t believe that is a fault of Holmes, so much as one of TSR. With the Holmes Set, they knew they needed an intro set, but did not want to stray too far from LBB’s.  The Moldvay edition is clearly an attempt to go mass and be a true introductory RPG set of rules for kids.  While not called out, the Holmes Basic cover art (knight, wizard, dragon) feels better for intro game imagery than the EO cover of Moldvay. Certainly the Mentzer Basic edition Elmore cover is the most professional and “best” from a Mass Market appeal view.

Third, the market has changed since the earlier rules edition. The first D&D market was made up of game buffs and college students. Today, the majority of D&D players are high-school and junior-high students. The new rules edition takes into account the younger readership in its style of writing.

Again the market seems to be the driver here.  Realizing the influx of young people interested in playing, and having not made a rules set able to let them play, the Moldvay boxed set attempted to become that introduction.  As a wee lad of 11 who started with this box set I can say the tone, rules layout, and description’s were perfect for me. I learned to play and understand RPG’s because of this set. I am sure other’s learned from LBB’s or the Holmes edition, but this set feels like and reads like a true introductory set more so than the other two.

Fourth, the TSR staff had answered thousands of rule questions; play tested countless dungeons at conventions, and received myriad letters detailing players’ experiences with D&D game rules. Because of the accumulated experience of the staff, and the help of the gamers, we could now pinpoint which rules needed additional clarification. When I edited the D&D Basic rules, I tried to stress clarity, simplicity, and conciseness. The organization of the rules was particularly important since the rules would set the format for all other rule books in the D&D system, such as the D&D Expert rules.

Brilliant, Moldvay/TSR knew in advance where the trouble spots were in learning and designed/edited a rule set to cover those questions a newbie might have. Second they insured the Basic rules would naturally flow into the expert rules.  These long visions for rules development allowed for player growth, ease of player transition to more complicated rules, and insured a cohesive presentation and tone to new players.  That is no small feat, and one I have not seen executed as well since.

One important point to keep in mind when reading the D&D Basic rules is that they are not hard-and-fast rules, they are rule suggestions. The system is complete and highly playable, but it is flexible enough that Dungeon Masters and players need not fear experimenting with the rules. DMs and players, by mutual consent, are always welcome to change any rule they wish, or to add new rules when necessary.

This is one place I have to disagree with Moldvay.  When trying to teach someone the basics of play one should focus on presenting hard and fast rules.  When you say these are the rules…but you don’t have to play this way, I think it adds to confusion both for players and a new DM.  I remember arguments pretty early on over the rules because of this flexibility which derailed some games.  I think this sort of flexibility is better left to Expert rules which assume a certain level of comfort and knowledge.

Because of this rule flexibility, individuals who learned to play using the original D&D Collectors Edition rules, or the earlier edition of the D&D Basic rules, can use the new edition without changing their campaign.

Not sure how many veteran players needed this?

Much of the work put into the new edition was in reorganization. Whenever possible, step-by-step instructions were given because that type of direction is easiest to understand. Numerous examples were added, because examples often clarify rule descriptions.

A strength of the rules was the play examples which not only give a flavor to the game but show the mechanics in action.  We referred to these a lot for clarification when learning.

The edge of the booklet was drilled with holes so that it could be placed in a notebook, thus cutting down on the usual wear and tear the rulebook takes.

Never liked this and people who did put them in binder wound up with ripped books.  Second you created a boxed set, and by the very nature of it being boxed, it implies the game lives in the box.   Otherwise why make a box?  Odd decision and shows the gamers are in charge.

The rules were organized into a number of different sections which logically build on one another, are easy to follow and read, and are easy to find by using the Table of Contents. Furthermore, the general section headings will remain the same for all rulebooks in the D&D system. All gaming terms are defined before the actual rule sections begin, and the definitions are repeated in a glossary.

This was exceptionally helpful in learning and referring to the rules, especially for a beginner.  Again the great design and fore thought to make D&D a unified rules set split into learning step books was a great decision. 

From a sales perspective you are going to get people to purchase at least 2 boxed sets to play.  Versus AD&D where really only the DM needs all the books, and a player should only have one the PHB.  As these boxes and rules books each contain player and DM info together, everyone should have a boxed set. 

I think something similar could (should) be done today, break the game up into levels: Starter 1-3, Basic 4-7, Intermediate 8-11, Expert 12-15, Advanced 16+.  Then create world boxes, or monster boxes, or campaign boxes. This creates a lot of shelf space spread, insures multiple purchases, and lowers the knowledge/ reading retention required. In fact one could create dungeon boards and sell card booster encounter packs. This may not work for old gray gamers—but they will buy stuff anyway, you goal is acquisition of new blood.  The Basic set did that, and could again if done with the same forethought and design principles.

Finally, the rules were indexed. My favorite two sections of the rules were Part 8: Dungeon Master Information and page B62, dealing with Inspirational Source Material. Much of the information given in these two sections is new.

Great reference for simple instructions on how to play and where to find ideas.

Many players feel that becoming a DM is difficult. I tried to make it as easy to become a DM as possible. After all, DMs like to play too, but if there is only one DM per group, that person never gets the chance to play. Novice DMs are given detailed instructions and as many helpful tips as possible.  The rules include a description of typical dungeon scenarios and settings. They give suggestions for common types of room traps, treasure traps, and special trap types. They provide a simple system for creating an NPC party.

These were extremely helpful and easy to understand.  That many gamers still use these charts 30 years later is a testament to Moldvay getting this spot on.  Its simplicity, elegance, and usefulness have stood the test of time brilliantly. As a whole these tools allowed you the novice to try your hand at making a game like the designers.  Think about that. You go to a store and no other game of the time Monopoly, Risk, Bonkers, Life, Othello, Panzer Blitz, Battleship, etc. let you get in and really make your own game world and adventure in it.  It is the single greatest strength of RPG’s, relying on player imagination, that still makes them a viable and long lived gaming platform.  Moldvay’s DM section opened that door for me and blew me away.

Finally, they outline a sample dungeon, designed so that, if desired, one section could be played immediately. I also enjoyed sharing my favorite books and authors with readers. I have always found books to be excellent inspirational material when designing adventures. I am sorry that, because of space considerations, the list could not have been longer.

These are the haunted towers, and again another brilliant design decision.  One tower was ready to explore and the second was left to you the budding DM to experiment with!  You could see how the expert did it, and then have a go yourself!  I think I have stocked that tower a dozen different times.

 The Basic D&D game rules are directly based on the original Collectors Edition rules. The original rules gave the first gaming system for fantasy role-playing and, in my opinion, the D&D game rules remain the best fantasy role-playing rules available to game enthusiasts.

Here Moldvay is kissing the ring and probably trying to stem the worry of the Old Gray Gamers.  I don’t necessarily think this is necessary to say, and could cause confusion as they are far and away a streamlining and clarification of the original LBB’s.  Having read in succession the LBB’s, then Holmes Basic, then Moldvay in more recent years I really see Moldvay Basic as the Homo Sapien evolution of the D&D rules.

I am proud to have edited the new edition of the D&D Basic Set rules. It was our intent to retain the flavor of the original game while improving upon and extending the rules, so that the game could be more quickly and more easily enjoyed by new players. I believe our efforts were a success.

Mr. Moldvay’s edition was a tremendous success, and historically an important corner stone in the growth and foundation of RPG gaming as a whole.  It codified, cleaned up, streamlined and presented in a simple way the complexities of game with no board, no pieces, and no winner.  These rules presented a revolutionary game that could last hours, days, weeks, months or years and was only limited in the end by your imagination.  A game which 30 years later remains as fresh and inspiring to me at 41 as it did to my when I first tore off the plastic wrap in 1981. 

Dragon Magazine #52: Basic D&D Boxed Set 2nd Edition, Tom Moldvay Editor

Issue #52 of Dragon Magazine features articles from Tom Moldvay AND Dr. J. Eric Holmes looking at the basic boxed sets for D&D.  They are very interesting to me for any number of reasons.  As the Moldvay boxed set is where I started, I will start with Moldvay's article on the 2nd edition D&D Basic boxed set.  , I think my historian background requires me to simply let you read the article for yourself  first prior to adding any commentary. I will follow this post later with a commentary.

by Tom Moldvay
Editor, second edition
D&D® Basic Set rules

Why was a new edition of the D&D® Basic Set rules needed?

First of all, it was necessary for the Basic rules to be in the same format as their sequel, the D&D Expert Set rules. Otherwise, it would be difficult to use the two sets together, as they were meant to be used. The D&D Expert rules build on the D&D Basic rules, they do not replace them.

Second, good as it was, the earlier edition still had minor flaws. The large number of questions received by TSR Hobbies showed that many areas of the D&D rules were still difficult for beginners to grasp. It was necessary to reorganize and re-edit the rules, keeping in mind that most new D&D players are not hard-core gamers and have never played a role-playing game before.

Third, the market has changed since the earlier rules edition. The first D&D market was made up of game buffs and college students. Today, the majority of D&D players are high-school and junior-high students. The new rules edition takes into account the younger readership in its style of writing.

Fourth, the TSR staff had answered thousands of rule questions; play tested countless dungeons at conventions, and received myriad letters detailing players’ experiences with D&D game rules. Because of the accumulated experience of the staff, and the help of the gamers, we could now pinpoint which rules needed additional clarification. When I edited the D&D Basic rules, I tried to stress clarity, simplicity, and conciseness. The organization of the rules was particularly important since the rules would set the format for all other rule books in the D&D system, such as the D&D Expert rules.

One important point to keep in mind when reading the D&D Basic rules is that they are not hard-and-fast rules, they are rule suggestions. The system is complete and highly playable, but it is flexible enough that Dungeon Masters and players need not fear experimenting with the rules. DMs and players, by mutual consent, are always welcome to change any rule they wish, or to add new rules when necessary. Because of this rule flexibility, individuals who learned to play using the original D&D Collectors Edition rules, or the earlier edition of the D&D Basic rules, can use the new edition without changing their campaign. Much of the work put into the new edition was in reorganization. Whenever possible, step-by-step instructions were given because that type of direction is easiest to understand. Numerous examples were added, because examples often clarify rule descriptions. The edge of the booklet was drilled with holes so that it could be placed in a notebook, thus cutting down on the usual wear and tear the rulebook takes. The rules were organized into a number of different sections which logically build on one another, are easy to follow and read, and are easy to find by using the Table of Contents. Furthermore, the general section headings will remain the same for all rulebooks in the D&D system. All gaming terms are defined before the actual rule
sections begin, and the definitions are repeated in a glossary.

Finally, the rules were indexed. My favorite two sections of the rules were Part 8: Dungeon Master Information and page B62, dealing with Inspirational Source Material. Much of the information given in these two sections is new. Many players feel that becoming a DM is difficult. I tried to make it as easy to become a DM as possible. After all, DMs like to play too, but if there is only one DM per group, that person never gets the chance to play. Novice DMs are given detailed instructions and as many helpful tips as possible.
The rules include a description of typical dungeon scenarios and settings. They give suggestions for common types of room traps, treasure traps, and special trap types. They provide a simple system for creating an NPC party.

Finally, they outline a sample dungeon, designed so that, if desired, one section could be played immediately. I also enjoyed sharing my favorite books and authors with readers. I have always found books to be excellent inspirational material when designing adventures. I am sorry that, because of space considerations, the list could not have been longer. The Basic D&D game rules are directly based on the original Collectors Edition rules. The original rules gave the first gaming system for fantasy role-playing and, in my opinion, the D&D game rules remain the best fantasy role-playing rules available to game enthusiasts.

I am proud to have edited the new edition of the D&D Basic Set rules. It was our intent to retain the flavor of the original game while improving upon and extending the rules, so that the game could be more quickly and more easily enjoyed by new players. I believe our efforts were a success.

Sunday, June 26, 2011

WotC D&D layoffs


Four conclusions I will draw:

1) D&D 4th is done
2) D&D based boardgames are doing well
3) More D&D boardgames will continue to come out
4) A new D&D version will come, a new direction, and headed by different folks

I think a streamlined "old school" version that ties to board gaming seems likely.

To highlight from a comment post I made:

If I were running it I would go back to a 3 step brand presentation for D&D using historical elements:

1) Basic D&D would be board game based like Dungeon: introduce character classes as game pieces, monster lexicon, and simple d20 systems.

2) Expert D&D would also be board game based like HeroQuest and Ravenloft. Now get into BASIC character creation and adventure creation, add the notion of different dice doing different things.

 3) Advanced D&D is a full blown RPG building on each of the previous steps.

If you have read and followed my missives before this, you saw it coming, if not? Well why not?

Friday, June 24, 2011

Out of the pocket and into peril!

Mike over at Swords and Dorkery (LOVE the blog name) has had his players going through part of a Pocket Full of Peril #5. I like that he is using them the way I intended, just tossing them in when (or where) they fit and changing, adding, or mixing to fit his own stuff.

They fit on note card and are perfect as a sort of DM crib sheet adventure.  Head over and see his report.  When I get a break from designing Rogue Space stuff, I will have to make another couple Pockets full of Peril.

Sunday, June 19, 2011

My Favorite Traveller movie

In the distant future, a police marshal stationed at a remote mining colony on the Jupiter moon of Io uncovers a drug-smuggling conspiracy, and gets no help from the populace when he later finds himself marked for murder. 

 1981's OUTLAND, staring a shotgun toting Sean Connery, is the movie that most defines my vision of the RPG Traveller.  It's gritty sci-fi feel, has enough common touches to not seem overly fantastic.

Yes you are on Jupiter's moon Io, but its a mining station, and the company is concerned about production and profit.  To that end an unscrupulous manager has narcotics smuggled in which make people work like a horse-but they go crazy after about 11 months.

Into this Sean Connery comes in and has to decide if he will play along or buck the system.  Alternately part western, and part sci-fi, it never strays into the space fantasy of most sci-fi films.  Outland is more Blade Runner than Buck Rogers in its dealing with sci-fi, and is an underrated classic in my opinion.  Having just seen it again this Friday, it still holds up well and frankly could be remade easily.

I never liked the "royals in space" conceit of Traveller and Outland fit more how I saw the Traveller Universe: more advanced with space travel, but still the same human problems and issues.  In fact one of the reasons I loved history all my life is regardless of the tools and civilization man develops, the one unchanging constant throughout is man.  Stone, spear, sword, sabre, shotgun, or stun rifle the hand holding the evolving technology remains unchanging.  Outland reflected that idea brilliantly, and in a sci-fi setting it shaped and reflected how I played and viewed Traveller.

Give it a watch and see if you see what I see.

Saturday, June 18, 2011

Rogue Space: STARSHIPS

With much struggle its finally done...in 8 page pocket format glory! See it on my Rogue Space site!

Thursday, June 16, 2011

So True

I attended college in Portland in the early 90's.  I still love visiting the city, the public library, Powell's books, catching a Winterhawks game, and exploring all the beers.  IFC runs a show called PORTLANDIA that skewers the city quite well, and in the best way possible.  To give you a peak at Portland's vibe see the great clip below.


Thursday, June 9, 2011

Dungeon Crawl Classics Beta, a different view

As everyone is throwing about their opinions on the beta edition of DCC I thought I’d provide my own take.  Mine will not be as game play focused as most others, instead I want to look more at the market potential: 

The D&D based fantasy rpg market:
D&D is still the 800lb gorilla, but they have vacated the throne, at least for now.  Most popular and retail selling games use the OGL, thus serving to further its system dominance as the default RPG game engine. Pathfinder (using an OGL 3.5 engine) is the current king with D&D 4th behind it in terms of sales.  Castles and Crusades remains a solid alternative and quietly goes about its business of replicating an old school feel with modern OGL rules.  The video game based Dragon Age continues to sputter along and seems to be gaining in acceptance.  In terms of the current retail fantasy market, these represent the bulk of D&D based game play sales.

OSR Influence
The rise and influence of Old School Renaissance gaming (OSR) has spawned numerous games based on early D&D rules: Swords & Wizardry, Labyrinth Lord, OSRIC, Dark Dungeons, Lamentations of the Flame Princess, Delving Deeper, and a host of others seek to replicate in their own way the spirit and game play of the earlier D&D editions.  Each in their own way appeals to a specific edition fan, but only a few have broken into retail, and none have created a critical mass necessary to sustain a full line of products.  Of these OSR editions Swords & Wizardry, Labyrinth Lord, and OSRIC seems to be the front runners currently, but none has the broad brand recognition necessary (yet) for critical mass appeal, interest, support, and fan identification at retail.

In addition, an attempt to latch onto the OSR influence and appeal to older gamers, D&D attempted a series of 4th edition boxed sets harkening back to the “Red Box” era of the basic game. Certainly the nostalgic and others picked up these boxes, but it did not appear to resuscitate nor enliven interest in a steadily decreasing consumer base of 4th edition D&D products.

Summary
D&D 4th and the RPG market in general are in decline.  The decline is a combination of being overshadowed by pick up and play electronic gaming, declining retail market access, graying of player base, and barrier to entry.  Barrier to entry can be construed as difficulty to pick up and play, need for items outside the basic book, time investment necessary by more than one player, and the need to create content and adjudicate rulings on your own.

Into this market, DCC sallies forth!

Art
DCC seems decidedly set to appeal to established or long term fans of fantasy literature and gaming.  In appearance it looks more like the art from books or magazines in the 70’s or earlier.  One might term it classic sword & sorcery in appearance.  Interior illustrations further the retro product feel.  While this will appeal to gamers who grew up with that art, will it appeal to the broader current Pop culture market? I am talking about fans of anime inspired art from comics, World of Warcraft, Final Fantasy, or other well known electronic gaming?  Probably not.  So this (from an art perspective) seems to appeal to older and current RPG fans.  It does not seem to have much potential to inspire pick up and buy interest from a current pop culture fan or non-rpg player who passes it on the shelf.  That may further limit its ability to get placement outside hobby stores.

Game Design
DCC Uses a modified and somewhat simplified/house ruled version of D&D 3.X,  This twist on 3.X rules may appeal to fans of the current RPG leader Pathfinder as well as reaching out to OSR fans.   Without a doubt it is the best “bridge” product I have seen trying to appeal to both fan bases. In trying to serve two masters though, will it end up pleasing neither?  Too early to tell, but it seems safe to think that it will create a fan base pulling from both established player pools.  Can it bring new people in?  Only if it reaches a buzz level of coolness like D&D and Pathfinder did.  Will it appeal to 4th ed. D&D fans?  I am not a 4th edition player and my limited experiences with it do not lead me to believe this will convert them…unless, Hasbro continue to let D&D slide then something will fill the gap.

A major hurdle is the use of Zocchi dice.  I understand the “street cred” this may seem to give the system, but is the decision to create an additional barrier to entry to playing (for both current gamers and any potential new ones) really the right thing for a new game system in a declining market?  I can understand having bonus charts that use a d30…maybe…but the reasons to use these from a business standpoint is beyond me.  They are not widely available at retail nor distribution, nor common in a current gamer bag…and no way anyone outside the industry even knows what this means? This seems like an absurd business decision and could torpedo the system before it leaves dock for the open sea. 

Beta Delivery
Offering the beta PDF beta free is great advertising and buzz building, but why not get betas printed and out?  Pathfinders option to let you buy the beta in physical form to switch people was a brilliant move, sad DCC is not following this.  If it were me, I’d leave the PDF free, and offer the printed beta at cost or cost +$5 or something similar.  Get people walking around with it, bringing it to the table to play, pass around, and lend.  Guerilla gaming! PDF’s are great for yourself but a physical book is free advertising to people who do not go to your site or know about your game.  Second the printed beta clearly did not impede sales of the full edition Pathfinder book so I don’t think it would be a financial issue.  This is a missed opportunity in my opinion.

Support
One of the benefits DCC has it’s the vast range of potential support material.  Goodman Games has created a wide range of settings, modules, and boxed sets especially during the 3.5 glory days of D&D.  I think it will be relatively easily to recycle this support material into their new DCC format.  That means boxed sets like Castle Whiterock could easily be updated and made available again.  The costs for Goodman being limited to printing and updating.  New cover art or at least layout/design would probably help establish the brand identity better. 

Secondly this vast back catalog makes the line instantly supported.  There should not be dead months or quarters while awaiting new material, it just needs editing and republishing.  So the line should have good support to give players the sense it will be around for awhile, and this should allow DCC to create a retail presence at launch.  This is a distinct resource advantage no other burgeoning line currently has available to it.

The downside of the back catalog is the potential for distributors, retailers, and players to think “I already have that” and some may avoid purchasing revised or updated items.  I believe by using a range of items based on previous sales data DCC could safely come out with revised or updated materials that would be picked up. 

The possible pitfall in putting these revisions out as “value priced” editions.  Once you head down the discounting or value priced road, you are setting expectations for what anything from the line should cost.  Second you are now causing consumers to set up value comparisons for your products like “both modules are 32 pages, but the revised one is only $10 while the new edition is $15.” Why should I pay $5 more?  When you get people into questioning you pricing instead of valuing the content, you have lost them.  DCC may consider a 2 or 3 for one “adventure path” scheme where you get two or three revised modules in one campaign book for $20. 

Now you would get more content than a new edition, but you are paying more for it too. This also makes it easier (cheaper) to do one new cover for multiple revised adventures.  The key is adding value to revised editions at a higher reasonable price point without sacrificing or derailing your frontline new offerings-both must have value to a consumer. 

Overall, the amount of product support and potential profit here is staggering in a declining market.  More so because any missteps learned from the DCC line (such as bad module sales, or poorly received series) are instantly avoidable. 

In the end I see the pro’s as:
1)    a current void in the market
2)    a bridge product to appeal to the two biggest gaming circles
3)    a grass roots pre-launch “buzz edition”
4)    a back catalog of readily available support material

I see the con’s as:
1)    focused appeal artwork may not reach outside current market
2)    decline in retail space for product
3)    creating new barriers to anyone playing: Zocchi dice
4)    revised products/pricing could be seen as negative by buyers, retailers and consumers.

Only time will tell.